Eyewitness  News
  • Home
Sunday, March 26, 2023
  • Home
  • Diplomacy
  • ECONOMY
  • Agriculture
  • Faith
  • Security
  • Tourism
  • International
  • Latest News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Diplomacy
  • ECONOMY
  • Agriculture
  • Faith
  • Security
  • Tourism
  • International
  • Latest News
No Result
View All Result
Eyewitness  News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Diplomacy
  • ECONOMY
  • Agriculture
  • Faith
  • Security
  • Tourism
  • International
  • Latest News

UHRC TRIBUNALS ILLEGAL

August 10, 2018
in Latest News
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

OPINION

UHRC TRIBUNALS ILLEGAL

RelatedPosts

Monitoring of Local Gov’ts Lacking-MPs

Parliament Rejects Govt Report for Lack of Quick Interventions.

Opposition Call off Parliament Boycott

By Peter Magomu Mashate,

At the heart of constitutionalism and rule of law is the doctrine of preservation and upholding of Human rights. For example, the right to Life is absolute and non- negotiable and every country worth of its salt legislates for this objective. In the UK its via the Human rights Act 1998 whereas in Uganda its via Article 51 of the Constitution of Uganda.

The role for the interpretation of the Constitution of Uganda is vested in the Constitutional Court when anomalies and contradictions become apparent. The doctrine of Separation of Powers is as non-negotiable as the application of the constitutional provisions themselves and Parliament in its wisdom provided mechanism within the constitution for resolving any contradictions. This is invariably the case in all universal democratic dispensations. Therefore, acting out of whim and/or outside the constitution may be arguably ultra vires (unlawful).

The Uganda Human Rights Commission is a Constitutional Organ pursuant to Article 51of the Constitution, hence, Article 51 (1) states thus;

“(1) There shall be a commission called the Uganda Human Rights Commission.

(2) The commission shall be composed of a chairperson and not less than three other persons appointed by the President with the approval of Parliament.

(3) The chairperson of the commission shall be a judge of the High Court or a person qualified to hold that office”.

Therefore, Article 51 (2) and (3) respectively prescribe sine qua non – (non negotiable constitutional essential conditions) that are absolutely necessary for a legitimately constituted and judicially viable Human Rights Commission.

Parliament must have intended and therefore vested judicial powers and the inherent judicial wisdom relating to such fundamental human rights issues in the hands of a qualified and competent Chairman heading and in concert with the other three members (Commissioners) regardless of their judicial qualification, save for, their moral uprightness enshrined in 51 (4)-therefore a facti, not juris to constitute the quorum besides the position of Chairman. This question of quorum is a constitutional provision and as the UHRC stands to date is inconsistent with the provision article 51 and therefore without lawful mandate to do business.

It should be clearly underlined, unless, constitutionally rebutted to the contrary that the function within the meaning of 51(2) relating to the functions of the Chairman are non delegable to the three Commissioners particularly if their competence and or indeed qualification are inconsistent with article 143 of the Constitution of Uganda relating to appointment of judges and judicial officers.

Parliament may have missed the opportunity to rectify this apparent contradiction in the Human Rights Commission during the passage of the operationising Human Rights Act and the only way forward is to normalise it by way of Statutory Instrument to the Human rights Act and better still amendment to Article 51of the Constitution. The role and functions of the Chairman is juris and sine qua non.

I would most respectfully submit that the Regional tribunals as previously constituted in absence of an enabling legal instrument may have not been in accordance with the letter and spirit of the Constitution and in particular article 51 and article 143 relating to qualifications for the appointment of Judges. Even if the regional tribunals headed by any of the Commissioners (besides the chairman) were assisted by an Advocate or State Attorney this would not be compliant with Article 51 as the decisions are of the Commissioner not the support staff by whatever name called. The way around it is to have Commissioners who are compliant with article 143 of Uganda’s Constitution. In any event, human rights are “Dead Serious non-negotiable matter”.

If so, all their adjudications and judgements to date may be ultra vires (Illegal). Even if they are deemed to have been legally constituted, which is vigorously disputed, they may have been constituted at variance with the letter and spirit of the Constitution which takes precedence in event of ambiguity or conflict of laws.

It would seem to me that while article 51 (3) specifically stipulates the attributes of a Chairman the rest of the article in relation to qualifications of the three Commissioners remains silent.

This is not unconstitutional after all it was the intention of Parliament which further prescribed the appointment of the membership of the Commission in general without specific attributes in 51 (2) but deemed it necessary to specify in 51 (3).

On this basis its arguable that the function and judicial obligation expressed and or implied in 51(3) cannot be delegated because had Parliament deemed it so, it would have specified as indeed it deemed necessary at article 51 (3).

The other pertinent question inevitably up for debate is as to whether or not the Regional Tribunals have had the Constitutional mandate to operate with a single Commissioner even in the light of the Human rights Act which is subject to the supremacy of the constitution in any event. My take is that they are illegal and negate the letter and spirit of the constitution in the light of such fundamental significance of the UHRC to a free and democratic people of Uganda. It is important and urgent to normalise quorum and constitutional compliance of the UHRC to avoid future litigation and hefty pay out in costs at the expense of the tax-payer.

In England and Wales, by statute, the Justices of the Peace do not require legal training qualifications. However, candidates must demonstrate six ‘key qualities’ – Good Character; Commitment and Reliability; Social Awareness; Sound Judgement; Understanding and Communication; Maturity and Sound Temperament. Once appointed, magistrates undertake mandatory training and are always supported in court by a trained legal advisor to guide them on points of law and procedure. The Clerk’s duty is non-delegable as its juris. It would probably be more difficult for the Chairman of the Uganda Human Rights Commission to delegate and or even derogate from Article 51 of the Constitution of Uganda.

The way out of this quagmire is for the Appointing Authority to do the needful and fully constitute the Commission in accordance with article 51 (2). Further and alternatively, for the Attorney General to come to Parliament and cause an amendment to Article 51 and or by way of statutory instrument revisit the Human Rights Act particularly in relation to regional tribunals as a matter of urgency because the human rights commodity is the most precious commodity for all citizens of our country Uganda.

The writer is a Barrister-at-Law, Lincolins Inn ( London).

Previous Post

MPs Urged to Legislate on Cyber Crimes

Next Post

Newly Mulago Women’s Hospital -Nearing Completion

Related Posts

Monitoring of Local Gov’ts Lacking-MPs
Latest News

Monitoring of Local Gov’ts Lacking-MPs

January 19, 2023
0

Inspection and monitoring of service delivery at local government level remains wanting, according to a section of Members of Parliament...

Read more
Parliament Rejects Govt Report for Lack of Quick Interventions.

Parliament Rejects Govt Report for Lack of Quick Interventions.

April 12, 2022
Opposition Call off Parliament Boycott

Opposition Call off Parliament Boycott

November 20, 2022
Aringa MP- Calls for More Funds For Yumbe Regional Hospital

Aringa MP- Calls for More Funds For Yumbe Regional Hospital

December 7, 2021
Oulanyah Rallies Agago to Take up Vaccination

Oulanyah Rallies Agago to Take up Vaccination

December 4, 2021
Health Consumers Push For Patients’ Rights Law 

Health Consumers Push For Patients’ Rights Law 

October 26, 2021
Next Post
Newly  Mulago Women’s Hospital -Nearing Completion

Newly Mulago Women’s Hospital -Nearing Completion

Monsanto ordered to pay $289 million in world’s first Roundup cancer trial

Monsanto ordered to pay $289 million in world's first Roundup cancer trial

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Phaneroo Boss, Sudhir Grilled Over Nakawa Land

Phaneroo Boss, Sudhir Grilled Over Nakawa Land

April 22, 2022
MPs – Reaction to The State of Nation Address

West Nile MPs, Govt Chief Whip Clash Over Electricity in the Region

January 15, 2023
Peter Magomu Mashate is a London based Ugandan Barrister of the Honourable Society of Lincoln’s Court in London

Ugandan Lawyer Mashate: The Unsung NRM Hero!

March 24, 2019
Gov’t Procures Sh1.9b Bone Marrow Transplant Machines

Gov’t Procures Sh1.9b Bone Marrow Transplant Machines

November 14, 2022
Budget Advocates Concerned With New Wave Of Corruption In Govt.

Budget Advocates Concerned With New Wave Of Corruption In Govt.

1
Musoke Ibrahim a father to Rahim who is now eight years

Being A Good Father Does Not Mean Money But Love & Care

1
URBRA Cautions On NSSF Mid-Term Access 

URBRA Cautions On NSSF Mid-Term Access 

1

Hello world!

0
Discussion To Downsize Parliament  Is Good- Obua

Discussion To Downsize Parliament  Is Good- Obua

March 24, 2023
Govt Entities Struggle to Pay Water Bills.

Parliament Will Not Be Intimidated Over Anti-Homosexuality Bill – Speaker

March 23, 2023
Uganda Parliament Passes The Anti Homosexuality Bill 2023

Parliament Honours Late Speaker – Oulanyah

March 23, 2023
Museveni Rallies Ugandans To Embrace-PDM

UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Urges Museveni  Not to Sign – Anti-Homosexuality Bill

March 22, 2023

Recent News

Discussion To Downsize Parliament  Is Good- Obua

Discussion To Downsize Parliament  Is Good- Obua

March 24, 2023
Govt Entities Struggle to Pay Water Bills.

Parliament Will Not Be Intimidated Over Anti-Homosexuality Bill – Speaker

March 23, 2023
Uganda Parliament Passes The Anti Homosexuality Bill 2023

Parliament Honours Late Speaker – Oulanyah

March 23, 2023
Museveni Rallies Ugandans To Embrace-PDM

UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Urges Museveni  Not to Sign – Anti-Homosexuality Bill

March 22, 2023

Eyewitnessug.com is Licensed by Uganda Communications Commission (UCC) Under Dominion Media Limited.

Dominion Media Limited is registered by Uganda Revenue Authority.

For Advertisement Reach out to Marketing Department via.
Email: [email protected]

Contact us through our Postal Address.
P.O.BOX 21157 Kampala-Uganda.

Browse by Category

  • Agiriculture
  • Agriculture
  • Business
  • Development
  • Diplomacy
  • ECONOMY
  • Editor's Pick
  • Education
  • Entertainment & Arts
  • Enviroment
  • Faith
  • Feature News
  • Governance
  • Health
  • International
  • Latest News
  • obituary
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Politics
  • Security
  • Social
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Tourism

Recent News

Discussion To Downsize Parliament  Is Good- Obua

Discussion To Downsize Parliament  Is Good- Obua

March 24, 2023
Govt Entities Struggle to Pay Water Bills.

Parliament Will Not Be Intimidated Over Anti-Homosexuality Bill – Speaker

March 23, 2023
  • Home

© 2023 Allrights Reserved EYEWITNESS NEWS UGANDA

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Diplomacy
  • ECONOMY
  • Agriculture
  • Faith
  • Security
  • Tourism
  • International
  • Latest News

© 2023 Allrights Reserved EYEWITNESS NEWS UGANDA

error: Content is protected !!